Skip to content

Why People With ADHD and Autism Get Blamed for Not Caring- August Gorman, Imi Lo

  • by

Why We Blame People Whose Minds Work Differently

When somebody does not do what most people do without thinking, we tend to decide very quickly that they do not care. A friend arrives twenty minutes late and we take it as a sign that they do not respect our time, and a colleague who looks away while we are talking seems not to be listening to us. August Gorman, a philosopher at Oakland University who writes about moral responsibility, disability, and mental health, thinks that we are often wrong about this. In our conversation on The Intense Mind, August argued that many of the rules we use to judge each other’s behavior were made by and for people whose minds work in one common way, and that people whose minds work differently put a great deal of effort into not being misjudged, and other people rarely see that effort.

August’s interest in blame started with their own misophonia. Misophonia means that certain soft, repeated sounds that people make, such as chewing or sniffling, cause a reaction close to fight or flight, and so August either wants to snap at the person or leave the room. They started to experience it at around twelve and did not find a name for it until they were nineteen or twenty. As a child they felt that they should not be blamed for saying “chew with your mouth closed,” and yet they could not explain why, and it seemed different to them from somebody who cares a lot about table manners and tells people off. I have misophonia too, and I told August that I do not know a single person in my own life who has it.

When August found a news article about misophonia and showed it to their family, the family started to treat it differently, and they no longer took offense when August wanted to eat in another room on holidays. August found it interesting that an official-sounding name could change so much about how people behaved toward them. 

When August read the philosophy of moral responsibility, they noticed that philosophers have written for decades about addiction, trauma, and psychosis, almost always through extreme and imagined cases, and have used those cases to ask what such people lack that the rest of us have. August thinks these cases give the wrong idea, that a few people are very different and everybody else works in the same way. In their view, nobody’s mind works in one correct way, and everybody differs from other people in many ways, in how they pay attention, how they remember, how they manage their feelings, and how easily they start a task.  

One of the examples August uses in their work comes from aphantasia, which means that a person cannot form pictures in their mind. In the example, a father and son are buying sunglasses for the mother, and the son asks whether a pair would suit her. The father says that he has no idea, and when he explains that he cannot picture her face, the son is upset and wonders whether his father loves her at all. August thinks they may have aphantasia themselves, and when they ask students to close their eyes and picture an apple, some students see it in full color and can turn it around, while others see nothing at all. For years August assumed that phrases like “picture this” were figures of speech, and I had made the opposite assumption, that everybody saw what I see. August says there are two ways we could respond when we learn about aphantasia. We could keep blaming people who cannot picture the face of somebody they love, and make an exception only when we find out that they have aphantasia. Or we could give up the assumption altogether, and accept that we do not know whether being able to picture a face has anything to do with how much a person cares. 

Many people think of eye contact as natural and necessary, and yet for some people it does not come easily, and trying to keep it up can make it harder to listen. August’s spouse is autistic and makes eye contact so that people feel listened to, and August knows that when their spouse is doing this, they are probably following less of what is being said. In a job interview, a person who looks away in order to listen to the questions may be judged as rude or uninterested, and that can cost them the job. August also pointed out that when small misunderstandings like these happen every day, they have a large effect on a person over the years.

Toward the end of our conversation, I asked August what any of us could do about this today. August said that we can choose to be open-minded, modest, and slow to judge. We can practise the virtue of mildness- it means waiting a moment before we decide what somebody’s behavior means, and asking ourselves whether it might have nothing to do with us, and whether something might be going on in the other person that we do not yet understand. August pointed out that we do not know how most other people’s minds work, and that even if we were all taught more about it, every person would still be different. 

About August Gorman

Dr. August Gorman is an Assistant Professor of Philosophy at Oakland University. Their research focuses on agency and moral responsibility, disability, and the philosophy of death, and they are currently writing a book arguing that philosophers should adopt a neurodiversity paradigm when they write about moral responsibility and the ethics of blame. Before joining Oakland University in 2022, August was a postdoctoral fellow at Princeton University’s Center for Human Values and at Georgetown University’s Kennedy Institute of Ethics. They received their PhD in philosophy from the University of Southern California in 2018, with a dissertation on moral responsibility.

https://www.augustgorman.com/

 

Imi Lo is a psychotherapist and consultant who has dedicated her career to helping emotionally and intellectually intense people turn their depth into strength. She has written three books with Hachette: Emotional Sensitivity and Intensity, The Gift of Intensity, and The Gift of Empathy.

Imi has over fifteen years of clinical experience, including roles with Médecins Sans Frontières and the NHS (UK), and holds three master's degrees in Mental Health, Buddhist Studies, and Global Cultures. Her training includes art therapy, philosophical counselling, Jungian psychology, mentalization-based treatment, EMDR, Schema Therapy, mindfulness-based and trauma-informed modalities, and she works integratively with psychodynamic, philosophical, and creative methods.

You can contact Imi for a one-to-one session tailored to your specific needs.

Leave a Reply