Skip to content

Please Do Not Ask Me Why I Am Depressed

How ‘well-meaning’ support can hurt the emotionally intense person

When you are gifted, emotionally intense, and highly sensitive, even the most ordinary expressions of concern from the people who love you can hurt in ways that are almost impossible to explain. The things that wound you do not always make sense to anyone else. Sometimes they do not fully make sense to you either. The difficulty may be that the things you need do not fit into the standard repertoire of comfort and support. And when you finally, after long deliberation and usually out of sheer desperation, allow your vulnerable side to be seen, what comes back can be as short and blunt as a single word: “why?”

The question “why are you depressed?”, or “what happened?”, is usually asked by friends and family with the best intent. But just because the intention is good does not mean the questions land lightly. When you open that window for your depression to come out, and what comes back is a blunt “why, what happened?”, it leaves you in an impossible position.

On the one hand, it kind of hurts because the question is reductive. It is asking you to produce an external cause for something that does not have one. Your sadness, as it lingers in a deep depression, has no starting point, no single cause, no event you can isolate and hand over. Your depression, like a perpetual dark fog in your living room, was lingering and present yesterday, and it will be lingering and present tomorrow.

You may have some ideas about the “why.” Maybe it is the existential anxiety, the feeling of despair about the state of the world, regrets about the past, a sense of meaninglessness, the absurdity of life itself. But anything you can put into words that the other person is able to hear is never going to capture it.

If you were to come up with words or some forced external reason, you already know you will feel more unseen than you did before you opened your mouth. When you have just opened the most protected part of yourself and what comes back is a two-word “what happened?”, something closes down. It sometimes comes with a sense of humiliation, of being diminished, being forced to perform “ok”, being cornered to paint a rosy picture when you are scrambling just to survive. And it is worse when they then start to offer practical suggestions or simplistic solutions. However well-intended, you immediately know that the fixing is for them, not for you. It may quiet their anxiety about your pain, but it does nothing for your despair and aloneness.

Those around you, however well-meaning, do not seem to get that chronic depression, existential or otherwise, has no clear, external cause. It is like a monster that you cannot control and can only learn to live alongside, day by day, with patience and acceptance and very little else. And the most galling assumption the people around you make is that there must be an external cause, that “something” must have happened, like a situation, a conflict, an event that explains everything. But it is not like that. The weight is already there when you open your eyes in the morning. Sometimes with a trigger, but often not. Every ordinary act of the day costs effort that nobody around you can see. Getting out of bed, getting dressed, all cost something. From the outside, you look like a person moving through a normal morning, but from the inside everything is mathematics: you are meticulously calculating the opportunity cost of everything you do to make sure you spend the very limited energy you have on the right things.

As an intense and likely neurodivergent person, you have always been pushed to perform normal. You are loved and adored and people want to be around you when you are solid, happy, your “normal self.” When you are there for them, listening to them, offering clarity and warmth when they need it. That is the version of you that earns closeness, the version of you that people stay for.

But the other version of you, the one who is drowning, intensely sad, in existential despair, the one whose inner world is too vast and too dark to fit into polite conversation, that version has always been too much. You learned early that people want to be around you when you can squeeze yourself into a category they can make sense of and understand, when you can edit the true valence of your inner state into a lukewarm language that passes for day-to-day conversation, when you can dilute the degree of your sorrow into something you can talk about after you have briefly discussed the weather.

Then, perhaps, you learned that the price of belonging is compression. Even when it feels forced, congested, diminished. What you have to do to “pass” in this world is to take everything you actually feel, make it smaller, make it lighter, make it manageable for the person sitting across from you, and only then are you allowed to stay in the room. Love has always felt conditional.

And that is why the simple question, “depressed, why?”, hurts the way it does. It is, without knowing it, asking you to shrink and edit again. To answer the “why” in a simple line is to take the uneditable thing inside you and translate it into a version that is bearable for them.

*

And since you are now stuck and they are waiting for an answer, you sometimes resort to finding one for them. But then something worse may happen. Sometimes, you get something back that feels like a shattering dismissal.

What you feel as a shattering dismissal may, once again, sound like ordinary conversation to most. “Oh, that? That is not a big deal.” “Many people have been through much worse.” Or, “I have been through worse than that myself.” The words are so common, so banal, so much a part of how people normally talk to each other, that the person speaking them does not hear what you hear, which is: you need to justify your depression to me. Suddenly, you feel like your pain has not crossed the moral threshold to be legitimate. And that happens to be your worst fear to begin with.

For the person who already suspects that their own pain is fraudulent, who already carries a deep and largely unexamined belief that they do not deserve to have needs, this reconfirms the inner voice that has always told you: your suffering is not real, you are too privileged to complain, you are ungrateful, you are burdening others for complaining. There are people going through worse in the world and you are being spoilt. Stop, or everyone will desert you.

Perhaps the person blurting out these words may genuinely be trying to help. They may believe, sincerely, that if they can show you that your situation is not as bad as you think, you will feel better. But however well-meaning, their intervention has pushed you into a darker corner. Now you are no longer just depressed. You are in a double, triple bind where you feel completely alone in the world for not being able to explain your depression, resentful at being asked to edit and deliver a neat answer, and angry with yourself for being in the state that you are in.

“All I feel are the assaults of apprehension and terror at the thought that I am the only one who is entirely unlike the rest. It is almost impossible for me to converse with other people. What should I talk about, how should I say it? – I don’t know.”
― Osamu Dazai, No Longer Human

*

You are not expecting the world to speak your language, or to cater to you. You are not a monster who demands therapy from friends and family. In fact, the most rational, resilient, and compassionate part of you knows your friends and family love you and are doing their best. You know the “why” comes from affection, from helplessness, from a person who cannot bear to watch you suffer and needs to do something to feel like they are helping. You know that when they guess, when they say “is it work? Is it your family? Is it that thing from last month?” they are not being reductive on purpose. They are reaching for the only tools they have.

You know that when they offer positive reframes, they are trying to pull you out because your pain is intolerable to them. When people compulsively reduce your suffering into a fix, it is likely a defence against their own helplessness. The underlying logic seems to be that, if they can convince you to see the bright side, then you are not helpless, and neither are they, and neither of you has to sit with the plain reality that sometimes people suffer, and there is nothing anyone can do about it.

And perhaps when they go quiet, when they change the subject, it is because they know they cannot help and are scared that trying will make it worse. Their withdrawal comes from a place of fear, though for your inner child it lands as abandonment or indifference.

Perhaps the rational part of you knows all of these things. But sometimes, on the days when even getting up is a battle, you have no more energy for empathy. You have no more energy for translating the good intent behind their hurtful words, for seeing behind their withdrawal into their vulnerability, for being the one who understands everyone’s position and holds it all together. On some days you simply cannot be the bigger person in the room. You cannot manage their needs on top of your own.

*

Another problem is that the word “depression” itself has been hollowed out. It has been used so casually, so loosely, so reflexively in everyday conversation and across social media that it no longer communicates what it is supposed to communicate. The word has been so misused in day-to-day language that it has lost its clinical, its existential, its human weight entirely. It is melancholy, existential despair, the slow disintegration of the felt sense of being alive. Depression is not a transient emotion. It does not always have a particular object. It is a pervasive alteration of the entire felt sense of being alive. The capacity for pleasure goes dark, the future collapsing into doom. The body becomes heavy and slow and unresponsive to things that used to excite you. But these days, if you were to use the word “depressed”, people may hear a bit of a mood, something that should pass, something fixable with a good night’s sleep, a walk in the park, a change of perspective. Toxic positivity tells you to focus on the good things, to practise gratitude, to choose happiness. Self-help culture tells you to identify the problem, eliminate the cause, and bounce back. Badly done cognitive therapy tells you you are “catastrophising.”

*

You have spent your entire life being the one who holds things for other people. From childhood, life has been about being there for others. You read the room before anyone else did, absorbed the tension, managed the conflict, looked after the emotional needs of the people who were supposed to be looking after yours. Friends come to you with their problems, talk to you about the intricate details of their lives, lean on your clarity and your patience, and you give willingly because it comes naturally to you. You are always there for others. You are always the empathic one. But when you fall, no one is there.

And so when the depression comes, and you are running out of ability to carry it alone, the decision to open up to someone is an act of enormous courage and enormous risk. And when you did, and the response was dismissal or comparison or cheerful reframing, it feels as though your trust was shattered and stepped on and thrown away. The complete existential despair that follows plunges you into the depth of a lifelong sorrow because it has touched the original wound: the knowledge, carried since childhood, that you will always be the one who understands others and never the one who is understood. And the belief that no one in the world will ever be able to hold you, get you, or be there for you.

*

If you could write the script for the people who love you, it would not be complicated. You would not ask them to understand. You may ask them to stop trying so hard to understand, and instead to accept that inside of you there is a deep, dark, hollowing despair. If possible, you would ask if they can sit with you in the room and let the depression be in the room too, without asking it to explain itself, justify its presence, or asking you to make it smaller so they can breathe.

But even if no one can do that for you, please know that you are not without hope.

You have been in this place before: dark, hollowing, swallowing. And though the darkness never fully goes away, it could fade into the background. It is not always of the same shape and the same weight. There are days when the darkness is lighter, smaller, more survivable.

The truth is, you have gotten out of the darkest corner before, not because someone came and pulled you out but because you kept going on the days when keeping going was the hardest. Your strength has never looked the way other people’s looks, but that quiet strength is what keeps you upright when everything in you wants to collapse.

It carried you through every other time the weight became unbearable, and it will carry you through this one, too, at its own pace, in its own time, without needing you to perform recovery for anyone else’s comfort.

Imi Lo is a psychotherapist and consultant who has dedicated her career to helping emotionally and intellectually intense people turn their depth into strength. She has written three books with Hachette: Emotional Sensitivity and Intensity, The Gift of Intensity, and The Gift of Empathy.

Imi has over fifteen years of clinical experience, including roles with Médecins Sans Frontières and the NHS (UK), and holds three master's degrees in Mental Health, Buddhist Studies, and Global Cultures. Her training includes art therapy, philosophical counselling, Jungian psychology, mentalization-based treatment, EMDR, Schema Therapy, mindfulness-based and trauma-informed modalities, and she works integratively with psychodynamic, philosophical, and creative methods.

You can contact Imi for a one-to-one session tailored to your specific needs.